True Blood does seem to be causing a stir amongst a number of friends and family. Several people have checked in with me to see if I've been watching and if I like it, given what they (think they) know about my taste in reading materials.
So what do I think?
Well ...
As you know, I'm a huge fan of the books. I have also been enjoying the series up to a point (this past week's episode being an exception -- I believe it was episode 6). But I'm having a bit of a mental jarring sensation while watching it. For those of you who are newly-acquainted with Ms. Harrison, I'll give you a bit of a crash course in how the show relates to the books. So far, at least.
Plot Point | True Blood (HBO Series) | Dead Until Dark (Book) |
“V” | Drug of choice | Doesn’t exist in the books |
People possessed by “demons” | Big thing with Tarra’s mother and, it appears, now with Tarra | Doesn’t exist in the books |
Graphic sexual depictions | True | Not so much |
Gothic, Anne Rice feel | True | False |
Grandmother murdered | True | True |
Character | True Blood (HBO Series) | Dead Until Dark (Book) |
Sookie as telepath | True | True |
Sookie’s rationale for staying in the house after grandmother’s murder | Unclear | Clear |
Sookie losing virginity to Bill | True – happens after grandmother dies; very stylized and gothic and melodramatic | True – low-key; happens after grandmother dies but he is there to support her |
Sookie having friends | True – in the series, her circle of friends include Sam, Arlene, Tarra and Lafayette | So-So – in the books, she is friends with Sam and Arlene … Tarra is a distant acquaintance/old friend, and |
Jason as a horn dog | True | True |
Jason involved in rough sex | True | So so |
Jason as suspect in murders | True | True |
Jason’s new girlfriend | Character created for tv series | Character doesn’t exist in the books |
Jason as “v” (or other kind of drug) fixated | Exists only in the tv series | Jason, although a horn dog in the books, does not have a drug issue of any kind |
Tarra as main character | True | False- she is a secondary, recurring background character in the books |
Tarra as Sookie’s best friend | True | False – friend from childhood, but not a focal-point friend in the books |
Tarra as strong-minded character who comes from a troubled background but who can take care of herself | True | False – Plays a character who comes from a problematic background who has daddy issues and tends to land herself into uncomfortable situations based on bad decisions she has made |
Tarra with crush on Jason | True | False – no connection between Tarra and Jason in the books |
Tarra, anti-vampire | True for tv series | False – she actually gets involved with a vampire in one of the later books who is a kind of “sugar daddy” for her for a while |
Sam watching out for Sookie | True – but in a protective, guy, sort of from a distance way | True – more of a key figure in Sookie’s life; helps her to clean the house when her grandmother is murdered |
Sam and Tarra involved | True for tv series | Sam and Tarra have no relationship of any kind in the books |
Eric as a character | Dramatic, one-dimensional character (so far) | Key recurring character; has a very ironic sense of humour in the books |
Arlene, anti-vampire | True | True |
I’m going to keep watching – of course. But it’s an effort to suspend my disbelief and experience the series as something separate and different from the original book(s).
For those of you who want spoilers, it seems that each episode is following the path of the chapters of the book – more or less. If you can look around the obvious plot differences, you can read the book Dead Until Dark to find out what happens, who (else) gets murdered, and who the murderer is.
No comments:
Post a Comment